City of Amaranthine Edit

Statue outside of ChantryEdit

(No approval changes regardless of options selected)

• I am Dalish. Of course I don't! (Dalish Elf only)
• I am a dwarf. We believe differently. (Dwarf only)
• I believe He exists, if that's what you mean.
• It's foolish superstition.
• I don't know what to believe.
  • You mean the spirits don't know?
  • I'm surprised spirits even think about it.
  • We don't know everything, either.
    • This world changes all the time, just not physically.
    • Clearly you think it should be.
    • Yes, I guess it would be, in comparison.

Vigil's Keep - Throne Room Edit

Kristoff's Chest, behind JusticeEdit

• Leave those alone. They’re not yours. (-2)
• That’s a little creepy, isn’t it?
• You can feel it? (+3)
  • Can you tell anything from these “fingerprints?”
  • When you die, there’s nothing left at all?
  • Isn’t that a little distracting?
    • You want vengeance?
    • If we can avenge him, we will/Yes, that's my hope. (+3) (ends conversation)
    • The darkspawn who killed him is dead.
    • Don’t worry about that. (-6) (ends conversation)

Note: In pc1.04, the line was "Yes, that's my hope", but it gave same approval

"This world is nothing like I thought it would be."Edit

• And thanks for that. We appreciate it.
• You barely know anything about it!
• Perhaps you should help us, instead. (+5)
  • Are you saying we’re friends, now? (+1)
  • So glad you approve. (+2)
  • Should I care what you think? (-10)
  • I’m not like most.
    • Raw lyrium is dangerous.
    • There are potions made of lyrium.
    • You’re no mage. What do you need lyrium for?
      • I’ll see what I can do. (+3)
      • I have no time to fetch you trinkets. (-1)
        Note: If already given Lyrium Ring then 3rd and the 4th round does not occur.

"I have been thinking of Aura, the mortal woman who was wife to Kristoff."Edit

• There’s no harm in wanting something beautiful. (+2)
• You should be careful. You’re not mortal.
• You aren’t taking it from them. There’s a difference. (+3)
  • Hey, it was an accident.
  • Thank you for remaining at my side. (+10) (note: approval varies)
  • I’m glad it isn’t the trial you thought it would be. (+6)

Vigil's Keep Edit

Confrontation with AuraEdit

Begins Justice for Kristoff
(First time entering Vigil's Keep with Justice in your active party; she is standing near a well in the central courtyard)

• Kristoff was killed by the Darkspawn
• Perhaps you should calm down…
• You were Kristoff’s wife?
  • Don’t worry about it. There’s nothing we can do.
  • Poor woman. It must be a shock to learn like this.
  • I didn’t know about her either, Justice.
    • You’ll just make her angrier. Let her grieve. (-3)
    • Kristoff’s life is not yours. Let it go. (-3)
    • Where would we even look for her? (+2)
      • That’s not a good idea. (-5)
      • Go find her, if that’s what you want.
      • I’ll see what I can do. (+4)

Wending Wood Edit

Elf Corpse in Velanna's CampsiteEdit

(Some choices are different for Dalish elves, as shown.)

• They are called the Dalish./We are called the Dalish.
• There aren’t many of their people around./We are the same people, but not of the same clan.
• Seems like they were outcasts, even amongst their own./We're not the same. They were outcasts.
  • Because we have never gotten along with elves. (Humans only)
  • Because humans hate my people, and always have. (Elves only)
  • The Dalish chose their path./My people chose our path.
  • I don’t know. Life is not very fair.
  • Because they’re not strong enough to fight. (-5)
    • We’re not as similar as you think.
    • I agree. It’s very pointless.
    • So we should all hold hands? Ridiculous! (-3)
    • I wish things were that easy.
      • Nothing wrong with that. (+3)
      • You can decide for yourself, you know. (+3)
      • That can’t be all there is to you. (-5)

Gift Edit

Lyrium RingEdit

Note: The gift yields max approval regardless of choices below (+20) .

• You found it, just as I asked of you. I am most grateful.
  • You're welcome.
  • It wasn't easily come by.
  • I hope it's useful.
    Note: If given before initial Throne Room discussion where he requests something made of lyrium, then the responses are different, and it appears max approval is (+18) .

Endgame Choices Edit

• Take Justice to Amaranthine upon receiving news of the attack on the city. (+2)
• Choose to save Amaranthine. (+2)
• Release the messenger. (-3)
• Choose to defend the Vigil's Keep. (-5) , but if persuaded (+2) .
• Return to the Vigil's Keep you chose to defend. If Justice was not in the party in Amaranthine, (+2) .
• Side with the Architect instead of killing him. (-5) with persuasion. Otherwise he becomes hostile. Depending on coercion, potentially (+2) .